Food safety is more crucial than ever.
With food recalls and illnesses frequently in the news, manufacturers must implement effective food safety management systems.
Fortunately, several food safety certification schemes, such as SQF and BRC, are available.
Let’s explore SQF vs BRC to determine which is right for your business.
SQF and BRC Overview
What Is SQF?
SQF (Safe Quality Food) is a food safety management certification created by the SQF Institute. It offers a systematic approach to managing food safety and quality, helping manufacturers reduce the risk of foodborne illnesses.
What Is BRC?
BRC (British Retail Consortium) is another food safety certification scheme created by the British Retail Consortium. It ensures that products are safe and of the highest quality.
What Is the Difference Between SQF and BRC?
BRC focuses on product safety and quality management systems, while SQF emphasizes food safety and quality management. BRC is more about consistency, and SQF is about preventing contamination and food safety issues. Both certifications are widely recognized in the food industry.
Certification Standards
- BRC: One standard.
- SQF: Four levels:
- Level 1: Food Safety Fundamentals
- Level 2: Certified HACCP-Based Food Safety Plans
- Level 3: Comprehensive Food Safety and Quality Management System
- Level 4: Advanced Food Safety and Quality Management
Certification Process
- SQF: Audits by licensed certification bodies, annual unannounced audits for all levels.
- BRC: Audits by accredited third-party bodies, unannounced audits at highest levels only.
Certification Cost
SQF certification can be more expensive than BRC, especially for small businesses, due to consulting, audit, and registration fees. However, SQF emphasizes food safety culture and detailed management systems, potentially improving operations.
Which Is Better: SQF or BRC?
Industry Sector
Choose based on your industry’s specific requirements. For canned goods, SQF might be more detailed, while BRC may suit fresh produce manufacturers.
Business Size
BRC is often more affordable and less time-consuming for small businesses, focusing on product safety and quality management systems. SQF requires more documentation and is more common with large retailers in the US and Canada.
Resources Available
SQF is more demanding and rigorous, requiring significant resources for compliance. BRC offers flexible, scalable solutions, making it a better choice for smaller businesses with limited resources.
Business Benefits of Certification
-
Improved Customer Confidence
-
Increased Market Opportunities
-
Reduced Risk of Product Recalls
-
Enhanced Company Reputation
Becoming Certified
Engage the certification body to conduct an audit and certify your business. Plan ahead, as this process can take several months.
Final Thoughts on SQF vs BRC
Both SQF and BRC are globally recognized food safety and quality management systems. The choice depends on factors such as organization size, product portfolio, market demand, and quality and safety objectives. Continuous improvement, effective communication, and stakeholder engagement are essential for sustainable results.